The Harris Poll® #5, January 29, 2003

Democratic Lead (Now Only Three Points) in Party Identification Has Declined to a New Low

Self-identified Conservatives now outnumber Liberals 2-to-1 but still trail Moderates
_____________________________________

by Humphrey Taylor

For the second year in a row, those who think of themselves as Democrats (regardless of how they actually vote) declined in 2002. The Democratic lead in party identification over Republicans has fallen from eight points in 2000 to five points in 2001 and only three points in 2002. Those who think of themselves as Democrats now outnumber Republicans by only 34% to 31% with 24% describing themselves as Independent, with the rest as not sure (6%) or something else (5%). This is the smallest Democratic lead we have recorded since we began measuring party identification in 1969, when Democrats enjoyed a 17-point lead over Republicans.

These numbers are based on replies to 13 nationwide surveys of adults surveyed between January and December 2002. These surveys were conducted by telephone with a total of over 13,000 adults (ages 18+). The numbers for previous years, since 1969, were all based on 10,000 or more interviews each year.

In the polls conducted in the 1970s we found, on average, a 21-point Democratic lead over the Republicans, with a peak of 25 points in 1975, the year President Nixon resigned. In the 1980s and 1990s, this Democratic lead declined to?11 and seven percentage points, respectively. In the first three years of this decade (2000 through 2002) the Democratic lead has averaged only five points.

Political philosophy

There has been little change in the proportion of adults who describe themselves as conservative (35%), liberal (18%) or moderate (40%) over the last several years. Indeed the numbers have been remarkably stable over the last thirty years. However, this is the first year since 1995 that conservatives have outnumbered liberals by more than two-to-one.

Those who think of themselves as moderate have been close to 40% for thirty years. Conservatives have been close to 35% for several years after peaking at 40% in 1995, after the "Republican revolution" and their midterm election victory of 1994.

Self-described liberals have never risen above 20% (in 1979) or fallen below 15% (in 1974). Since 1975, moderates have never fallen below 38% or risen above 42% (most recently in 1992).

Party identification is not a very good predictor of how people will vote

While most people who identify as Democrats or Republicans tend to vote for candidates of these parties, very large numbers of them do not. Furthermore, in recent elections, a majority of voters split their tickets and only a minority cast all their votes for candidates of one party (The Harris Poll #62, November 21, 2002).

For much of the last thirty years, more Democrats voted for Republican candidates than vice-versa, and majorities or pluralities of independents voted Republican. Otherwise, Republicans would have won far fewer elections. So, obviously, the continuing decline in Democratic identification does not bode well for Democratic candidates.

Humphrey Taylor is the chairman of The Harris Poll®, Harris Interactive.

TABLE 1

THE HARRIS POLL – PARTY AFFILIATION

"Regardless of how you may vote, what do you usually consider yourself – a Republican, a Democrat, an Independent, or some other party?"

Base: All adults

Year

President

Republican

Democrat

Independent

Democratic Lead

   

%

%

%

%

2002

Bush

31

34

24

3

2001

Bush

31

36

22

5

2000

Clinton

29

37

23

8

1999

Clinton

29

36

26

7

1998

Clinton

28

37

27

9

1997

Clinton

29

37

26

8

1996

Clinton

30

38

26

8

1995

Clinton

31

36

28

5

1994

Clinton

32

37

26

5

1993

Clinton

29

38

27

9

1992

Bush

30

36

29

6

1991

Bush

32

37

26

5

1990

Bush

33

38

25

5

1989

Bush

33

40

23

7

1988

Reagan

31

39

25

8

1987

Reagan

29

38

28

9

1986

Reagan

30

39

25

9

1985

Reagan

30

39

26

9

1984

Reagan

27

40

24

13

1983

Reagan

26

41

27

15

1982

Reagan

26

40

28

14

1981

Reagan

28

39

28

11

1980

Carter

24

41

29

17

1979

Carter

22

41

31

19

1978

Carter

22

43

30

21

1977

Carter

21

48

25

27

1976

Ford

24

47

24

23

1975

Nixon/Ford

21

46

27

25

1974

Nixon

23

45

32

22

1973

Nixon

26

48

26

22

1972

Nixon

30

47

23

17

1971

Nixon

31

49

20

18

1970

Nixon

31

49

20

18

1969

Nixon

32

49

19

17

NOTE: "Others" and "Not sures" excluded.

TABLE 2

DECADE MEANS OF DEMOCRATIC LEAD

"Regardless of how you may vote, what do you usually consider yourself – a Republican, a Democrat, an Independent, or some other party?"

Base: All adults

1970s

21%

1980s

11%

1990s

7%

2000’s (so far)

5%

TABLE 3

THE HARRIS POLL – POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY

"How would you describe your own political philosophy – conservative, moderate, or liberal?"

Year

President

Conservative

Moderate

Liberal

   

%

%

%

2002

Bush

35

40

17

2001

Bush

36

40

19

2000

Clinton

35

40

18

1999

Clinton

37

39

18

1998

Clinton

37

40

19

1997

Clinton

37

40

19

1996

Clinton

38

41

19

1995

Clinton

40

40

16

1994

Clinton

NA

NA

NA

1993

Clinton

NA

NA

NA

1992

Bush

36

42

18

1991

Bush

37

41

18

1990

Bush

38

41

18

1989

Bush

37

42

17

1988

Reagan

38

39

18

1987

Reagan

37

39

19

1986

Reagan

37

39

18

1985

Reagan

37

40

17

1984

Reagan

35

39

18

1983

Reagan

36

40

18

1982

Reagan

36

40

18

1981

Reagan

38

40

17

1980

Carter

35

41

18

1979

Carter

35

39

20

1978

Carter

34

39

17

1977

Carter

30

42

17

1976

Ford

31

40

18

1975

Nixon/Ford

30

38

18

1974

Nixon

30

43

15

1973

Nixon

NA

NA

NA

1972

Nixon

31

36

20

1968

Nixon

37

31

17

NOTE: NA means not asked

Methodology

This issue of The Harris Poll® is based on more than 13,000 interviews conducted by telephone within the United States between January and December 2002. Figures for age, sex, race, education, number of adults and number of voice/telephone lines in the household were weighted where necessary to align them with their actual proportions in the population.

In theory, with a probability sample of this size, one can say with 95 percent certainty that the results have a statistical precision of plus or minus one percentage point of what they would be if the entire adult population had been polled with complete accuracy. Unfortunately, there are several other possible sources of error in all polls or surveys that are probably more serious than theoretical calculations of sampling error. They include refusals to be interviewed (non-response), question wording and question order, interviewer bias, weighting by demographic control data and screening (e.g., for likely voters). It is impossible to quantify the errors that may result from these factors.

These statements conform to the principles of disclosure of the National Council on Public Polls.



©2003, Harris Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction prohibited without the express written permission of Harris Interactive.



Print
Printer Friendly Version of this Release

Follow The Harris Poll on:
twitter

Subscribe to Over the Wire – Weblog commentary of research data on current events and social trends
Sign-up for Harris Poll Weekly
About The Harris Poll
The Harris Poll by Date
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
Financial Times / Harris Poll
Search The Harris Poll Library
News Room
PRIVACYSURVEY DEMOESOMAR 26 QUESTIONSJOIN OUR PANELSITE MAPSEARCH

©2009 Harris Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.